I was recently in the market for a new laptop to replace my aging ProBook 4415S. It was a middle of the road HP business laptop from 2009, and over the years I’d upgraded the RAM to 4GB and installed an SSD, and replaced the battery three times. Even with those modifications it was still feeling the effects of six years of wear and tear, and so I demoted it to shop laptop and decided to pick up a modern replacement.
I thought for a long time about what I needed in a replacement machine. Gaming would be great, but I really wanted something with a long battery life and small form-factor. A high-resolution screen and good graphics was a must, too. I pretty much always have Internet access either at an access point or by tethering to my T-Mobile phone’s built-in free hot spot, and about the only thing I ever use a laptop for anyway is web browsing and document creation. I use a desktop at home for the heavy lifting.
Ultimately, I ended up with an Acer Chromebook 13, part of the CB5-311 series – it’s a big change of pace from my previous computers, but I think it’s the right choice. I’ve been using it for a solid 2 weeks as my daily-driver laptop and while not without a few quirks, I’m overwhelmingly both impressed and satisfied with its functionality and quality. Keep in mind throughout this review, that this is mostly just a platform for a web browser: there is limited to no support for apps and limited offline functionality of any kind.
The “CB5-311-T1UU” is a pretty impressive machine when compared with most of the other Chromebooks out there. It’s powered by a quad-core 2.1 GHz nVidia Tegra K1 CPU, nVidia Kepler GPU featuring 192 CUDA cores of the same variant found on desktop GeForce cards (in contrast, a middle-of-the-road current generation GeForce might have 1280-1536 of those same CUDA cores in it’s arsenal – but it’s an impressive graphics compliment for a lightweight device.) All this power pushes a 13.3″ 1080P Full HD screen backed by 4GB of RAM and a 32GB solid-state drive.
As far as ports go, there’s a pair of USB 3.0 host ports, a full-sized SD card slot, a full sized HDMI port, and the charging port. It also features the fastest and latest 802.11AC WiFi.
When closed, it’s less than an inch thick and weighs only 3.31 lbs., so light I barely notice it in my bag.
As mentioned before – it’s quite light, and the powerful CPU and GPU combined with the SSD make it incredibly quick to boot up, and I’ve been unable to get it to slow down and lag on me in normal usage. As I’m writing this, I have 11 tabs open including a large PDF, and it’s chugging along quite nicely. Transitions between tabs are quick and scrolling is smooth, although there is a small delay to render a change to the screen on the PDF that I don’t experience with the desktop when zoomed in on a big file.
The system boots up from cold in about 10 seconds, from powered off to usable, and it only takes about 5 seconds to restore from standby. Not bad at all! It’s also shockingly powerful. I was able to side-by-side stream a 1080P Netflix video, and a 1080P YouTube video simultaneously each on half the screen and neither suffered any lag, stuttering or artifacts.
Acer rates the battery at about 11 hours of usage in normal conditions, and I’d consider that accurate. I certainly manage a full day’s usage on a single charge, plugging in at night and using it in several 3 to 4 hour sessions throughout the day. I bet it would be possible to push 12 hours if you kept the brightness low and worked only one or two tabs at a time to keep the load down. And all this at $377 – a high end Chromebook for the price of a low end Windows machine.
I wasn’t sure if I’d consider the Chromebook an actual “laptop” at first, but I’ve decided it qualifies. There are a few differences, though.
The keyboard has dedicated Chromebook functions arranged in the top key row in place of function keys by default (although, you can override this in settings and turn them back into unlabeled function keys.) There are hard buttons for refresh, tile windows, brightness, sound, and a combination log-off/power-off button in the top right. There’s also a dedicated “Google Search” button in place of caps-lock which calls up a search box instantly from any screen.
The keys feel okay, but not great – they don’t offer a huge amount of tactile feedback, but I adapted quickly to the typing style. Some commonly used functions like Home/End/Page-Up/Page-Down are missing – but if you hold Search and press an arrow key those functions are available but unlabeled.
The touchpad is a little odd. It has a single physical button along the bottom but not marked separately on the surface. I found (and find) the mixed gesture input system a bit disjointed, personally. Tap or click to left-click, two-finger tap to right click, and a three-finger tap is a “middle click” to open in a new tab. Unfortunately, though, I find it difficult to actually touch three fingers to the surface closely enough in time to actually register a middle click and it ends up either left-clicking or right-clicking somewhat unpredictably. I’ve adjusted to just right-clicking and selecting “Open in New Tab” as appropriate.
- Browser Support
Although the Chromebook does manage to support Flash (as well as the latest and greatest HTML5 technologies), it’s uncommon enough that some sites don’t deal well with it. HBO Go, for example, won’t load. Installing the “User Agent Switcher” extension which lets you tell your browser to identify itself differently to a web site, and telling the browser to identify itself as Chrome for Windows instead of Chrome for Chromebook, seems to fix all of those problems. HBO Go itself works just fine when accessed with this trick, but it will give you a thoroughly broken text-only page if you’re identifying yourself with the default user-agent string.
- Power Management
Closing the lid puts the laptop to sleep but it continues to draw power, and it will do so until the battery dies unexpectedly, leaving you surprised and muttering expletives under your breath when you pull the laptop out and find yourself without any power. I’ve not found a setting to change the power management behaviors, either. Snapping the lid closed should only be for a short break – you should always remember to hold the power button down until it logs off, then powers off, to make sure you don’t drain your battery.
- VPN Support
Don’t count on a Chromebook to connect to most VPNs. Google’s Product Forums trash PPTP VPNs as being fundamentally insecure, and state that as a security-focused product (everything locally is strongly encrypted all the time) they won’t offer support for an insecure technology. In the same breath, they admit PPTP is better than nothing, but don’t support it and don’t have any plans to. Given that most commercial VPN services, workplace VPNs, and home VPN router hosts use PPTP this is incredibly frustrating. You’re stuck with a few variants of L2TP, and OpenVPN, if you want to secure your Internet traffic over your access point. Great if you’re a Linux system administrator in your spare time, less great if you want something that “just works”.
This lack of functionality means I’m looking for a replacement for my ~1.5 year old, $150 Asus router/access point, and frankly, it’s downright arrogant of Google to refuse to support the most commonly deployed VPN technology for questionable ideological reasons that won’t resonate at all with the general public.
I’ll rate this Chromebook a 4/5, overall, and give it my recommendation. At only $377, it’s capable enough and very portable which is the majority of what I want from a laptop these days. It’s not without some caveats, though, as noted above – and while you can get a Chromebook down to around $200, the less powerful versions might offer a noticeably less powerful experience and lower resolution screen. Either way, though, a $400 Windows laptop would be a very entry level piece of gear with poor battery life, so considering what you’re getting it works out very well.
It’s absolutely not for everyone: if you do any gaming at all, or need access to any apps at all, this isn’t the machine for you. On the other hand, if you’re mostly interested in browsing the web, streaming video and some light document creation this could be a good choice and it’s definitely worth looking into at least.