Cost Engineering in the 1930s

It looks like cost engineering was already happening back in the 1930s:

In the foreground, the destroyed original power transformer from the 1939 Zenith 7-S-363 radio; the rear, an equivalently rated replacement built in October 2010 by Edcor Transformer. In order to squeeze out a few cents cost savings per chassis, Zenith under-rated their power transformers and ran them right at the limit. In certain modes of tube failure, or just age and components wearing out, the power transformer’s razor-thin safety margin would be exceeded resulting in overheating, shorting and melting. Which is exactly what’s happened on the one I’m repairing at some point in its life.

Posted in Commentary, Radios and Tubes, Vintage | Tagged , , , | 3 Comments

Repairing a Vintage Radio (Coronado 907)

Coronado 907 - As Found

This is my first project, a 1940 Coronado model 907. This was originally a “high end low end” receiver: it only receives the AM broadcast band, but has three tone settings and mechanical push-button presets. It also uses 7 tubes when most common low-end sets used only five or six; more tubes = better quality. As you can see, it was a bit on the dusty side when I found it, having sat in someone’s basement for decades until they passed away and it was cleaned out at an estate sale. It cost $20, I didn’t want to spend much for something at this point.

Fortunately all the tubes are inside. When a set stops working properly due to “old age”, passive components wearing out, the tubes generally are still good. In this case 6 of the 7 checked out just fine and I had a spare handy for the other.

The most common mode of failure in an antique radio happens also to be the easiest to fix: bad capacitors. Manufacturing technology from the early days of electronics left a lot to be desired and after some time these would dry out and start leaking electricity from one side to the other. When this happens, the set will not play music, only playing a loud 60Hz hum independent of the volume level. If the radio is allowed to continue to run in this condition, will rapidly cause the transformer to short out and potentially destroy other components with it. Never, never plug in an antique radio if you don’t already know for a fact it works or has been reconditioned lately or you could cause permanent, expensive-to-repair damage. Or worse, start a fire. Even if you unplug it before it burns up, antique radio smoke can have some nasty stuff in it and smells horrible.

Moved to my workbench. The chassis is pretty once taken out of the dirty cabinet; it was well stored. Many antique radios have become rusty or infested with rodents at some point during their lifetime, but this one is remarkably clean.

The under side of the chassis is a bit less pretty to look at. The dark-tan cylindrical things are the old capacitors, which are almost universally leaky at this point. It’s a good idea to replace every capacitor in an old radio, if they haven’t failed yet they will soon. The colorful components are molded “dog-bone” resistors. The bright orange squares are new, modern capacitors I’ve put in to replace some of the old ones. Seen in this shot to provide a contrast between old and new.

Here, even more capacitors have been replaced with modern versions. These “orange drop” metalized polypropylene capacitors will probably not need to be replaced again during my lifetime, especially as the duty cycle on them is going to be very, very low.

The old parts I removed – capacitors and some extra solder. The largest one is a multi-section capacitor used in the power supply; the others are small signal capacitors used to help route electricity around the radio to different tubes depending on what task needs to be accomplished at the time.

Repaired and ready to put back in the case!

On the shelf, ready to display! I managed to get most of the grime off using a vigorous rubbing with Goop, followed by furniture polish – but it still needs to be stripped and sanded. That’ll be a project for better weather, Seattle winter in an apartment is not the best for doing work on furniture.

After repair, the radio plays loudly and with great tone. It’s a solid performer. There are some resistors that will need attention, but I was rushing this one through because I wanted to have it done to show off. I’ll probably do a follow-up to this one later to finish the job.

Posted in Projects, Radios and Tubes, Vintage | Tagged , , , , , , , , | 1 Comment

Meter Clock Roundup

Meter clocks are interesting works of geeky art that display the time using analog panel meters driven by a microcontroller. They can be strikingly artistic – and are getting to be very popular. There are a lot of homebrew designs that use a microcontroller and some small digital-analog converters to produce a signal for a variety of meter types. I’m working on one myself, but in the mean time, there are a lot of other ideas out there!

A gentleman named Andy has made this beautiful Geeky Clock that made it all the way to Hack a Day:

Servo Meter Clock

Andy has built his clock using servo motors to position the needles instead of meter movements, effectively making his meters from the ground up. I could see some advantages to this approach (more accurate control), but just driving an appropriate meter directly is a bit less work.

Another very interesting example of a meter clock comes from Len Bayles at ChronWorks, sellers of interesting clock merchandise including scopes and nixie tubes in addition to meters. He uses three 1 mA scale meters in a cluster and some DACs to drive this unusual set of gauges for hours, minutes and seconds. The full write-up including source files and parts lists is available over at his dedicated site for the meter clock, Meterclock.com.

These gauges draw more power (1 mA full scale) than the microcontroller or DAC alone could drive, so they are powered by a small amplifier to make sure they can move accurately.

There’s also the classic meter clock featured on Embedds.com using some seriously powerful meters – 50 mA full scale. In contrast, the meters I’m working on to build my small meter clock are 50-150 μA, about a thousand times more sensitive. These are mounted on a panel and it looks like a piece of test equipment or a rack mounted indicator display – interesting and industrial.

Another entry from Hack a Day shows off this elegant and incredibly wide arc meter “Clock for Geeks“, using a single face with a large area to allow it to display the time using a single servo-driven movement. A little big for my tastes, but very interesting!

from Chrass Landing comes the Anachronistic Chronometer. This one features some very stylish antique meters in the mA full scale range, one originally an ammeter and the others volt meters that can be driven the same way. The only unfortunate thing about it is he ruined an early 1920s vacuum tube radio to build this one:

“Meanwhile, I was checking Ebay for something steampunk-ish to put my clock into. Eventually I got the idea of using an antique radio. Not exactly steampunk, but the idea of an anachronistic “clock radio” seemed pretty funny to me. I settled on a home made 1920’s radio.” I think that radio was a kit radio from the 1920s, probably not an entirely homebrew one. But, whatever it was, he had the right idea with the meter placement. There were originally already viewing holes behind where those meters were mounted to let you look in at the tubes and see how brightly they glowed (and adjust their power using the knobs right below where the meters are now.) If left intact, that radio probably would have been worth a couple hundred dollars as-found or considerably more working.

But it does make a pretty neat clock.

Finally, one of the first meter clocks I discovered was several years ago, the original Chronulator. A kit you can piece together with μA-scale meters, I’m using it as the base of my clock project. Other people have made beautiful examples of Chronulators too, including this fine Steampunk Chronulator example made by a French designer:

As well as other craziness made from the same kit:

I wonder how long the Bombulator was left sitting by that planter. It looks like it could really attract some attention.

Posted in Collections, Electronics | Tagged , , , , , , | 1 Comment